Grouping of reviewer recommendations for the purpose of our analysis
Recommendations provided in the reviewer form | Recommendations grouped for our analysis |
---|---|
Accept without revision | Accept |
Accept after discretionary revisions | |
Accept after minor essential revisions | |
Unable to decide on acceptance or rejection until the authors have responded to the major compulsory revisions | Revise |
Reject because too small an advance to publish | Reject |
Reject because scientifically unsound | |
No recommendation | No recommendation |