Table 1

Randomised controlled trials in which loop ileostomy and loop colostomy in patients undergoing anterior resection were compared

AuthorNumberPrimary outcomeMain findingsConclusions
Williams et al3247 (23 LI vs 24 LC)Stoma-related morbidityLI: 3 (18%)
LC: 11 (58%)
Favoured: LI
Khoury et al3361 (32 LI vs 29 LC)Anastomotic leakage after primary surgeryLI: 2 (6%)
LC: 6 (21%)
Favoured: LI
Gooszen et al3476 (37 LI vs 39 LC)Stoma-related morbidityLI: 9 (24%)
LC: 1 (3%)
Favoured: LC
Edwards et al3570, (34 LI vs 36 LC)Clinically relevant anastomotic leakageLI: 2 (6%)
LC: 1 (3%)
More other stoma-related complications in the LC group
Favoured: LI
Law et al3680 (42 LI vs 38 LC)Ileus after primary surgeryLI: 6 (14%)
LC: 1 (3%)
5 cases of postoperative ileus, 2 of intestinal obstruction before stoma closure
Favoured: LC
  • LC, loop colostomy; LI, loop ileostomy.