Table 3

Summary of effectiveness of policies and non-policy interventions on outcomes, by the level of intrusiveness*†

Level of intrusiveness of the interventionsEver-use and/or initiationSusceptibilityBeliefs and perceptions on harms, risks and social normsAttitudes and behavioursKnowledgeReactions to or perceptions of the intervention’s effectiveness
Eliminate choiceEffective (four studies)Effective (one study only)Effective (one study only)Effective (one study only)
Restrict choiceEffective (one study only)
Guide choices through disincentivesNot effective (one study only)
Guide choices through incentives
Guide choices by changing default policyEffective (two studies)Not effective (one study only)Effective (two studies)
Enable choiceEffective (one study only)Inconclusive (two studies)Not effective (one study only)
Provide informationInconclusive (two studies)Effective (four studies)Effective (five studies)Effective (three studies)Effective (one study only)Effective (three studies)
Do nothing or simply monitor the current situationInconclusive (one study only)
Reorient government actionEffective (one study only)
  • *Only levels with evidence from the included studies shown.

  • †No studies were found that had policies or interventions guiding choices through incentives.