Table 2

Benefits of CEP teaching and assessment portfolios

CEP teaching portfoliosCEP assessment portfolios
Enhancing learning
Promotion of life-long learning104 106
Promotion of self-directed learning
  • Formulation of learning plans.90 96 126

  • Facilitates outcome-oriented learning.89 90 118 120

  • Enhances self-evaluative capabilities.73 76 80 85 88 89 100 104 106 112 126 127

  • Identification of strengths and weaknesses.69 71 76 78 92 96 100 101 109 128 129

  • Inculcates responsibility and ownership for one’s learning.71 73 74 80 84 86 113 118

  • Sets the pace.104

  • Personalised learning.109 129

Balance of structure and freeform learning69 76 92 128 130 131
Adaptable to goals77 98 132
Alignment of learning outcomes and assessment methods90 91 97 112 118
Allows personalised assessments77
Allows assessment over time84 92 and stages of development69 and that facilitate evaluation of:
  • Learning and progress over time.77 101

  • Learning curve.115

  • In different roles.92 93

  • In different settings.70 98

  • Complex behaviours.72 74 77 84 90 104 122 133

  • Critical thinking.77 97 112 132

  • Outcomes/competencies.128 133

  • Self-assessment.77 112 132

  • Complex skills.98

  • Professionalism.132

  • Cultural competence.132

  • Communication skills.132

  • Clinical ethics.134

  • Problem solving abilities.77 132

  • Reflective abilities.77 90 109 112


Longitudinal data
  • Possess good predictive value of subsequent clinical competency.74 135

  • Enhances validity of portfolio grading.69

  • Guides better decisions.74 122 136

  • Provides authentic assessment is a key principle of it.92 104 109

  • Provides insights in the various core competencies.106

  • Fair mode of assessment104 and allows student to defend positions/work.69

  • Provides students with direction and clarity.130 131


Allows the combination of summative and formative assessment69 91 and multisource assessments818797129109 and triangulation77 109
Facilitates personalised feedback122 that can be informed by understanding of the individual setting and context98 104 126
Personal and professional development
Promotes self-understanding79 114 115
  • Understanding feelings and thoughts.126 129

  • Understanding of one’s values.92

  • Understanding activity/experience.69 88 123

  • Understanding of how one functions in a team.122

  • Fears and stressors feelings of inadequacy.123 137


Curates evidence of skills106
  • Skills to compile a portfolio.102 106 130 138 139

  • Reflective skills.69 76 88 120 123 129 140

  • Clinical skills.104


Organises information120 128
  • Documentation of progress.77 100 101 106

  • Documentation of skills in different settings.71 101 109


Cross-sectional view of one’s competence69 77 101 109
Personalisation
Allows for personalisation69 90 104 113 132
  • Personal experiences.69


Choice over the contents69 104 132
Benefits to faculty
Improvement of curriculum83 92
  • Identify areas of weakness in curriculum.83

  • Provide insights into mentoring, teaching, etc.141

    Facilitates design of the programme.83

    Faculty development

  • Understand more about how students acquire competencies.104

  • Insight into the impact of their interventions.136 141


Insight into their professional conduct, role modelling and pastoral care115
E-portfolios
Ease of use:
  • Easier use.90

  • Accessible.73


Dissemination and editing of information113
  • CEP, communication, ethics and professionalism.