Table 2

Results of the prediction models

Audio_formatGenderML modelAccuracyOv.precisionPrecision_0Precision_1Ov.recallRecall_0Recall_1Ov.f1scoref1-score_0f1-score_1Weighted AUC
3gp (Android)FemaleLR0.770.770.810.730.770.760.770.770.780.750.85
KNN0.720.730.70.770.720.870.550.720.780.640.76
SVM0.80.80.80.790.80.840.740.80.820.770.86
VC0.780.780.810.750.780.790.770.780.80.760.86
MaleLR0.780.790.870.50.780.850.530.790.860.520.81
KNN0.830.830.830.80.830.980.270.790.90.40.84
SVM0.840.830.880.670.840.930.530.830.90.590.82
VC0.840.840.890.640.840.910.60.840.90.620.82
m4a (iOS)FemaleLR0.720.720.80.560.720.770.610.720.790.580.75
KNN0.680.650.720.50.680.860.290.650.780.370.67
SVM0.790.790.810.750.790.910.550.790.860.640.79
VC0.770.760.80.690.770.890.530.760.840.60.78
MaleLR0.730.740.830.480.730.80.540.730.810.510.8
KNN0.890.890.890.890.890.970.650.880.930.760.81
SVM0.850.840.860.760.850.950.580.840.90.670.85
VC0.890.890.890.890.890.970.650.880.930.760.85
  • The selected models were selected using Recall_1 and weighted AUC and are highlighted in bold. Class 0: no fatigue, class 1: fatigue.

  • AUC, area under the curve; KNN, K-Nearest Neighbuors; LR, logistic regression; Ov, Overall; SVM, support vector machine; VC, voting classifier.