Table 1

GRADE method for rating the quality of evidence

Study designQuality of evidenceLower ifHigher if
Randomised trialHighRisk of biasLarge effect
−1 Serious+1 Serious
−2 Very serious+2 Very serious
Inconsistency Dose response
−1 Serious+1 Evidence of a gradient
−2 Very seriousAll plausible confounding
Indirectness+1 Would reduce a demonstrated effect or
−1 Serious+1 Would suggest a spurious effect when results show no effect
−2 Very serious
Imprecision
−1 Serious
−2 Very serious
Quasi randomised trialModeratePublication bias
Low−1 Serious
Very low−2 Very serious