Table 1

List of comparison groups and definitions of control and treatment groups

ComparisonPattern of community asset participation
Control groupTreated group
A: 6-month uptake analysisNNNY
B: uptake sensitivity analysisNNNN?Y
C: 12-month uptake analysisNNNNYY
D: uptake sensitivity analysisNNNNN??Y
E: 18-month uptake analysisNNNNNYYY
F: 6-month cessation analysisYYYN
G: cessation sensitivity analysisYYYY?N
H: 12-month cessation analysisYYYYNN
I: cessation sensitivity analysisYYYYY??N
J: 18-month cessation analysisYYYYYNNN
  • Y indicates participation. N indicates non-participation. ? indicates either participation or non-participation.