Table 1

Summary of articles included in the review by regions

RegionCountriesReferencesStudy design
West AfricaNigeria=15 15 22 23 25 29 30 35 44 54 62 65 72 75 80 84 11 SA, 3 cross-sectional, 1 mixed methods
Ghana=5 27 40 41 90 94 3 SA, 2 cross-sectional
Benin=2 71 77 SA
Niger=1 97 Cross-sectional
Cameroon=1 69 SA
Burkina Faso=2 42 43 Cross-sectional
DRC=1 13
South AfricaSouth Africa=2 34 98 1 SA, 1 mixed methods
East Africa
Rwanda=2 52 81 1 SA, 1 cross-sectional
Malawi=1 95 Natural experiment
Kenya=5 9 70 79 82 92 3 SDA, 2 cross-sectional
Tanzania=4 53 89 96 100 2 SDA, 2 cross-sectional
Zambia=2 74 93 2 SDA
Zimbabwe=1 78 1 SDA
Ethiopia=24 24 32 46–48 50 51 55 56 58–60 63 64 66 68 77 83 85–88 91 99 6 SDA, 18 cross-sectional
Multicountryn=6 49 57 61 67 73 76 6 SDA
  • DRC, Democratic Republic of the Congo; SA, Secondary Data Analysis.