Table 5

The overall quality of measurement properties for each health literacy instrument used in children and adolescents

Health literacy instrumentInternal consistencyReliabilityMeasurement errorContent validityConstruct validityResponsive
ness
Structural validityHypotheses testingCross-cultural validity
NVS39 50 52?nana?na±nana
TOFHLA48nanana?nanana
s-TOFHLA50?nana?nanana
c-sTOFHLAd51++na++?+?na
REALM-Teen41 50?+na++na+nana
HLAB40+?na++nanana
MMAHL44++nana++− −nanana
MHL49?nana++na++nana
DNT-3953+nana?nanana
DNT-1453+nana?nanana
eHEALS43+na+++nana
CHC Test47na?na++?nanana
HKACSS46+++ (HC) − − − (HA)nana++na++nana
HLAT-5142?nana++?nanana
HLAT-845− − −nana?+++++nana
CHLT54+nana++++nana
VOHL55na− (TS) + (GS)nananana+
HAS-A56+nana+++nana
MaHeLi57+nana?+nanana
QuALiSMental64nana+++++nana
FCCHL-AYAC65+ (FHL) − (IHL) + (CHL)nana+++nana
ICHL58nanana++na+nana
HELMA59++++na++++nanana
HLSAC60++na+++nana
REALM-TeenS66++nana++na++nana
funHLS-YA61+nana?+nana
HLS-TCO62+nana++++nana
HLRS-Y63+nana+++++nana
p_HLAT-867+nana++++na
  • + or −, limited evidence and positive/negative result; ++ or − − , moderate evidence and positive/negative result; +++ or − − − , strong evidence and positive/negative result; ±, conflicting evidence; ?, unknown due to poor methodological quality or indeterminate rating of a measurement property; c-sTOFHLAd, Chinese version of short-form Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adolescents; CHC Test, Critical Health Competence Test; CHL, Critical Health Literacy; CHLT, Child Health Literacy Test; DNT, Diabetes Numeracy Test; eHEALS, eHealth Literacy Scale; FCCHL-AYAC, Functional, Communicative, and Critical Health Literacy-Adolescents and Young Adults Cancer; FHL, Functional Health Literacy; funHLS-YA, Functional Health Literacy Scale for Young Adults; GS, Gingiva Score; HA, health attitude; HAS-A, Health Literacy Assessment Scale for Adolescents; HC, health communication; HELMA, Health Literacy Measure for Adolescents; HKACSS, Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Communication and Self-efficacy Scale; HLAB, Health Literacy Assessment Booklet; HLAT-8, 8-item Health Literacy Assessment Tool; HLAT-51, 51-item Health Literacy Assessment Tool; HLRS-Y, Health Literacy and Resiliency Scale: Youth Version; HLS-TCO, Health Literacy Scale for Thai Childhood Overweight; HLSAC, Health Literacy for School-aged Children; ICHL, Interactive and Critical Health Literacy; IHL, interactive health literacy; MaHeLi, Maternal Health Literacy; MHL, Media Health Literacy; MMAHL, Multidimensional Measure of Adolescent Health Literacy; na, no information available; NVS, Newest Vital Sign; p_HLAT-8, Portuguese version of the 8-item Health Literacy Assessment Tool; QuALiSMental, Questionnaire for Assessment of Mental Health Literacy; REALM-Teen, Rapid Estimate of Adolescent Literacy in Medicine; REALM-TeenS, Rapid Estimate of Adolescent Literacy in Medicine Short Form; s-TOFHLA, short-form Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults; TOFHLA, Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults; TS, Tooth Score; VOHL, Visual Oral Health Literacy.