Table 3

Summary of evidence on outcomes

Outcome measureNo of studiesStudies with significant positive effectStudies with no effectBest evidence synthesis
Screening
Preferences for screening2One medium-quality/high-quality and one high-quality RCTNoneEvidence of positive effect
Intention to attend screening8One medium-quality RCT*One high-quality, one medium-quality/high-quality and four medium-quality RCTs*Evidence of no effect
Attendance at screening12One high-quality RCTTwo high-quality, two medium-quality/high-quality and seven medium-quality studiesEvidence of no effect
Health-related behaviours
Intention to change health-related behaviours
 To tan1One low/medium RCTNoneLimited evidence of positive effect
 To protect skin1NoneOne low/medium RCTLimited evidence of no effect
Health-related behaviours
 Smoking cessation1NoneOne high-quality RCTLimited evidence of no effect
 Smoking abstinence1One high-quality RCTNoneLimited evidence of positive effect
 Sun protection2Two medium-quality RCTsIndicative evidence of positive effect
 Tanning bed usage1NoneOne low/medium RCTLimited evidence
 Adult skin examination2Two medium-quality RCTsNoneIndicative evidence of positive effect
 Child skin examination1NoneOne medium-quality RCTLimited evidence of no effect
 Breast examination3Two high-quality RCTsOne medium/high RCTIndicative evidence of positive effect
 Diet0NoneNoneNo evidence
 Physical activity0NoneNoneNo evidence
 Alcohol0NoneNoneNo evidence
  • *One medium-quality study reported a significant positive effect in low-risk women and no effect in high-risk women.

  • RCT, randomised controlled trial.