Table 6

Ratings of methodological quality: strong, moderate and weak

StudySelection biasStudy designConfoundersBlindingData collectionWithdrawalsGlobal rating
Thewes et al, 200931ModerateModerateWeakModerateWeakModerateWeak
Braeken et al, 2009,26 201327 and 201328ModerateStrongStrongModerateWeakStrongModerate
Ito et al, 201125ModerateModerateStrongModerateWeakModerateModerate
Zemlin et al, 201129ModerateModerateWeakModerateWeakModerateWeak
Bauwens et al, 201430ModerateModerateWeakWeakWeakWeakWeak